Fungal Diversity
A new species complex including Claviceps fusiformis and Claviceps hirtella
Pažoutová, S.1*, Kolařík, M.1, Odvody, G.N.2, Frederickson, D.E.3, Olšovská, J.1, and Man, P.1
1
Institute of Microbiology ASCR, Vídeňská 1083, 142 20 Prague 4, Czech Republic
Corpus Christi Research & Extension Center, 10345 Agnes Street, Corpus Christi, TX 78406-1412
3
Formerly INTSORMIL, c/o ICRISAT Bulawayo Centre, Bulawayo, Zimbabwe
2
Pažoutová, S., Kola ík, M., Olšovská, J., Odvody, G.N., and Frederickson, D.E. (2008). A new species complex
including Claviceps fusiformis and Claviceps hirtella. Fungal Diversity 31: 95-110.
Isolates of Claviceps species with lunate to fusiform macroconidia were collected from panicoid grasses in Texas and
Zimbabwe and described as new species based on anamorphs since no teleomorphs were available. Characterization
was based upon morphology and partial sequences of rDNA and β-tubulin. The isolates grouped into two stronglysupported clades. The first clade contained ancestral C. hirtella and C. fusiformis from pearl millet (Pennisetum
glaucum) in clade terminal position with Texas isolates from native cup grass (Eriochloa sericea) and pearl millet
grouped between them. The second clade consisted of African isolates from Urochloa and Eragrostis. The isolates from
Texas from pearl millet and buffel grass (Cenchrus ciliaris) and isolates from E. sericea were described as new species,
Sphacelia texensis and Sphacelia eriochloae, respectively. Both species had morphology, DNA markers, and alkaloid
production that was intermediate between those features exhibited in C. fusiformis and C. hirtella. The African isolates
from Urochloa and Eragrostis were also described as a new species, Sphacelia lovelessii. In shaken cultures, C. hirtella
readily produced a whole range of clavines with agroclavine and festuclavine predominating, but ergometrine was also
detected. Claviceps fusiformis produced mainly agroclavine and elymoclavine, S. eriochloae produced mainly
agroclavine, elymoclavin and festuclavine and the cultures of S. texensis contained small amounts of agroclavine and
festuclavine. Only traces of clavines were found in cultures of S. lovelessii of the second clade. The alkaloid content of
infected florets in the sphacelial (honeydew) developmental stage was also measured. Only C. fusiformis and S.
eriochloae produced alkaloids in planta at this early stage.
Key words: alkaloids, β-tubulin, Cenchrus, Claviceps, clavine, conidia, Eragrostis, Eriochloa, pearl millet,
Pennisetum, phylogeny, Sphacelia, rDNA, Urochloa
Article Information
Received 28 May 2007
Accepted 18 October 2007
Published online 31 July 2008
*
Corresponding author: S. Pažoutová; e-mail: pazouto@biomed.cas.cz
Introduction
Since 1997, infections by Claviceps
species with lunate to fusiform macroconidia
have been found in Texas on heads of introduced pearl millet (Pennisetum glaucum),
buffel grass (Cenchrus ciliaris), and native
cupgrass (Eriochloa sericea). San Martín et al.
(1997) and Velásquez-Valle et al. (1998) detected similar infections in Mexico. However, no
teleomorphs of the parasites were observed,
mostly due to fungal hyperinfection, precluding
species description by traditional sclerotial
germination studies. Ergot disease of C. ciliaris
was observed in the late 1980’s in Texas (Craig
and Hignight, 1991) but the authors did not
describe the causal fungus. Morphologically
similar Claviceps anamorphs (sphacelia) with
fusiform to lunate conidia of unknown species
were also collected from Urochloa spp. and
Eragrostis sp. in Zimbabwe during 2000-2001.
In this paper we report the identity of these
fungi.
Only two species of Claviceps with
markedly fusiform to lunate conidia have been
formally described, both colonizing grasses
from Paniceae: C. fusiformis and the Australian endemite C. hirtella. In addition, there are
numerous records of sphacelial forms with lunate
conidia from various grasses and locations in
India (Table 1). C. fusiformis has been
described as the main ergot pathogen of pearl
millet or bajra (Pennisetum typhoideum, now
P. glaucum) in Africa and India (Loveless,
95
1967; Thakur et al., 1984). The oldest specimen of C. fusiformis came from Ghana in 1925
(Loveless, 1967). In Africa, C. fusiformis was
the typical ergot parasite of Pennisetum and
Cenchrus (Loveless, 1964a, 1967).
In India, the picture is more confusing.
Pearl millet was not initially recorded as a host
plant of ergot fungi with fusiform or lunate
conidia, but such fungi were recorded, although
not identified, on other panicoid grasses well
before the first documented epiphytotics of C.
fusiformis. The first record of an ergot with
long conidia (20.7 × 6.1 µm), later identified as
C. fusiformis (Siddiqui and Khan, 1973), refers
to pearl millet in Banaskanatha district in
Bombay State in 1955 (Shinde and Bhide,
1958). Shinde and Bhide (1958) also noted that
the asci and conidia of the fungus from pearl
millet resembled those observed by Thomas et
al. (1945b) on Pennisetum hohenackeri. The
following year, fully developed ergot infection
at severe incidence was recorded in Bombay
and Mysore states (Bhide and Hegde, 1957).
Pearl millet ergot remained little known in
other regions until 1966 when, with the introduction of the first generation of pearl millet
hybrids (HB 1 and HB 2), epiphytotics developed in other states (Sundaram et al., 1969).
In addition to Cenchrus ciliaris, Cenchrus setigerus and Pennisetum hohenackeri, the
unidentified Indian ergot anamorphs originated
from Panicum antidotale, Urochloa panicoides, Urochloa ramosa, and Paspalidium
flavidum (now Setaria flavida) (Ramakrishnan,
1937; Thomas et al., 1945a,b; Adyanthaya,
1946; Ramakrishnan, 1947). Cross-infection
experiments have shown that some of these
fungi possessed polygeneric host ranges.
Ramakrishnan (1947) infected Urochloa ramosa with conidia collected from Cenchrus
setigerus, whereas Thakur and Kanwar (1978)
succeeded in infecting pearl millet with an
ergot pathogen from Panicum antidotale.
The question of whether the pearl millet
ergot epiphytotics in India were caused by a
change in host of an indigenous population of
C. fusiformis already present e.g. that from
Cenchrus, or by introduction of an African C.
fusiformis more virulent to Pennisetum spp.
remained open. Similarities between the alkaloid composition of African and Indian isolates
96
do not preclude an introduction (Kumar and
Arya, 1978).
Langdon (1952) noted the similarity of
conidial morphology and host specificity of
Claviceps anamorphs with lunate conidia in the
Indian records to those of Claviceps hirtella
(Langdon, 1942). C. hirtella is the only Australian species colonizing Urochloa spp. Queensland Plant Pathology Herbarium harbours
specimens of C. hirtella from species of
Urochloa, Paspalidium, Eriochloa and Entolasia. Since 1976, C. hirtella has been repeatedly found on Cenchrus ciliaris (supposedly
introduced in 1870-1880), presenting thus a
problem for the seed industry.
In former Rhodesia (now Zimbabwe),
Loveless (1964a) defined 13 groups of Claviceps sphacelial anamorphs on the basis of
conidial morphology and host species. Six of
them were assigned to teleomorphs already
described (C. paspali, C. digitariae, C. sulcata,
C. maximensis, C. pusilla and C. cynodontis).
Since then, three new species have been identified with the corresponding morphological
groups: C. rhynchelytri, group No. 1 (Herd and
Loveless, 1965); C. fusiformis, group No. 7
(Loveless, 1967); and C. africana, group No.
10 (Loveless, 1964b; Herd and Loveless, 1965;
Frederickson et al., 1991). Two of the original
groups (No. 11 from Hyparrhenia spp. and No.
13 from Loudetia spp.) are still present in
Zimbabwe (Frederickson, 1990; Pažoutová and
Frederickson, 2005). No records of anamorphs
with lunate conidia on Eragrostis in Zimbabwe, and only one for Urochloa and Brachiaria in South Africa, 1988 (conidia measuring
13 µm × 4.4 µm and identity suggested to be
Claviceps sulcata), were mentioned in these
studies.
Sclerotia of African and Indian isolates
of C. fusiformis from pearl millet contain agroclavine and elymoclavine as the main alkaloid
components; minor or trace components are
chanoclavine, setoclavine, penniclavine and,
occasionally, festuclavine. Both also readily
produce clavines in submerged culture in vitro
(Banks et al., 1974; Bhat et al., 1976; Singh
and Husain, 1977; Kumar and Arya, 1978).
However, Janardhanan et al. (1982) detected
festuclavine as the major component, accompanied by agroclavine, and chanoclavine, in
sclerotia of Claviceps sp. with lunate conidia
Fungal Diversity
Table 1. A survey of Paleotropic ergot fungi with fusiform to falcate conidia.
Unnamed records:
Urochloa ramosa
Urochloa panicoides
Urochloa distachya
Setaria flavida
Panicum antidotale
Pennisetum orientale x
P. purpureum
Cenchrus setigerus
Cenchrus ciliaris
Described species:
Claviceps fusiformis
Claviceps fusiformis
Claviceps hirtella
Sclerotia
Conidial
shape
Conidial size (µm)
Citation
unknown
falcate,
pointed
fusiform to
lunate
14.6 < 19.8 < 29.2 × 4.4 < 5.8 <
7.3
12.8 < 15.4 < 19 × 3.2 < 5.1 < 6.4
(Ramakrishnan, 1937)
arcuate,
slightly
pointed
lunate
12.6-19 × 3.8-6.3
(Thirumalachar, 1945)
12.8 < 16 < 20.8 × 4.8 < 5 < 6.4
(Ramakrishnan, 1947)
11.4 < 21 < 28.6 × 3.9 < 5.3 < 5.8
(Janardhanan et al., 1982)
(Sundaram et al., 1969)
12.8 < 17.9 < 26 × 3.2 < 4.8 < 6.4
(Ramakrishnan, 1947)
14 < 18.4 < 25.2 × 5.0 < 5.96 < 8.4
(Adyanthaya, 1946)
fusiform to
lunate
9.5 < 15.8 < 22.5 × 3 < 3.6 < 5
(Loveless, 1967)
fusiform
12 < 15.9 < 26.4 × 2.4 < 3.9 < 6
(Thakur et al., 1984)
arcuate
11-16.5 × 4.5-6.5
(Langdon, 1942)
globose to
oblong,
brown,
1.5 × 0.6 mm
subglobose to
spherical
curved, brown
4-5 × 1 mm
unknown
unknown
unknown
unknown
obpyriform,
slightly
protruding
elongated to
round, brown
subglobose,
yellowish
brown
fusiform
fusiform
fusiform to
lunate
lunate
from Panicum antidotale. The same alkaloids,
plus elymoclavine, were found in submerged
culture isolates from this source, suggesting
that the pathogen may not have been C.
fusiformis. No information is available about
alkaloids of C. hirtella.
Crous and Groenewald (2005) stated that
taxonomic names based solely on fungal
phenotype often represent species complexes or
cryptic species, and not operational units. The
objective of this study was to assess the relationships of the existing species C. fusiformis
and C. hirtella to the anamorphs with lunate
conidia to determine if they represent such a
species complex. Characterization of the isolates was based on rDNA and partial β-tubulin
sequences, morphological markers and alkaloid
biosynthesis. An erroneous rDNA sequence,
AJ133392 for C. fusiformis, from a previous
study (Pažoutová, 2001) was also corrected.
Materials and methods
Herbarium specimens and isolates
The origin of specimens and isolates is
given in Tables 2 and 3. Specimens of Clavi-
(Ramakrishnan, 1947)
ceps hirtella, BRIP 16635 and 13544, and
monosporic isolates of C. hirtella were obtained from Queensland Plant Pathology Herbarium (BRIP, courtesy of Dr Roger Shivas).
Strain C. fusiformis 47A was isolated in 1957
from Pennisetum material originating from the
Ivory Coast (Tyler, 1958; Pažoutová and
Tudzynski, 1999). Strain C. fusiformis F27 was
obtained from the former Farmitalia collection
from Italy in 1983, but it originated from an
African Pennisetum specimen collected in the
1960’s. Pure cultures of Claviceps specimens
from Africa and Texas were isolated by plating
honeydew drops from florets of infected pearl
millet onto T2 agar and subsequent transfer of
agar plugs with germinating macroconidia
(Pažoutová et al. 2002). Only C. fusiformis
from India was purified from surface-sterilized
sclerotia (Pažoutová et al., 2000). Herbarium
Type specimens were deposited in the herbarium of the Mycological Department, National
Museum in Prague (PRM). Ex-holotype and
other representative strains were stored in
liquid nitrogen and deposited in the Czech
Collection of Clavicipitaceae (CCC; Institute
97
Table 2. Characteristics and origins of sphacelial specimens.
Species
Claviceps fusiformis
Specimen
Accession
Host
PRM 857332
Pennisetum glaucum
PRM 857331
Pennisetum glaucum
PRM 857333
Pennisetum glaucum
Sphacelia eriochloae
PRM 857335
Eriochloa sericea
Sphacelia texensis
PRM 857334
*
Eriochloa sericea
Cenchrus ciliaris
PRM 857338
Cenchrus ciliaris
*
Pennisetum glaucum
PRM 857336
Pennisetum glaucum
PRM 857337
Pennisetum glaucum
BRIP13544
Cenchrus ciliaris
BRIP16635
Cenchrus ciliaris
PRM 857342
Urochloa sp.
*
Urochloa trichopus
PRM 857340
Urochloa mosambicensis
PRM 857341
Urochloa oligotricha
PRM 857339
Eragrostis sp.
Claviceps hirtella
Sphacelia lovelessii
* Small specimens consumed by microscopy were not deposited
SD – standard deviation
98
Location
Shamva,
Zimbabwe
Matopos,
Zimbabwe
Gulbarga,
Karnataka,
India
Agua Dulce,
Texas
Kingsville, TX
Agua Dulce,
Texas
Kenedy
county, Texas
Weslaco,
Texas
Corpus Christi,
Texas
Weslaco,
Texas
Meandarra,
Queensland,
Australia
Blackall,
Queensland,
Australia
Matopos,
Zimbabwe
Matopos,
Zimbabwe
Matopos,
Zimbabwe
Matopos,
Zimbabwe
Matopos,
Zimbabwe
Year
Collector
Alkaloids
per
sphacelia
(µg)
6
Conidial dimensions (µm)
Length
SD
width
SD
9.5 < 18.9 < 27.5
3.7
3.9 < 4.8 < 6.3
0.4
1999
N. W. Mc Laren
2000
D.E. Frederickson
16
10.2 < 17.9 < 21.6
2.0
2.8 < 4.8 < 8.5
0.5
2006
R.H. Angadi
30
15 < 20.9 < 26.5
2.7
3.2 < 4.9 < 6.5
0.8
1997
G. N. Odvody
24
6.7 < 10.6 < 14.9
1.5
2.6 < 3.6 < 4.6
0.4
2006
1997
G. N. Odvody
G. N. Odvody
13
0
7.7 < 12.1 < 15.7
8.2 < 12.6 < 19.6
1.5
1.6
2.5 < 3.7 < 5.5
3.0 < 4.0 < 4.6
0.5
0.5
1997
O. Rodriguez
0
8.8 < 12.1 < 16.8
1.4
3.1 < 3.7 < 4.6
0.4
1998
G. N. Odvody
0
7.1 < 11.6 < 15.1
1.5
2.8 < 3.9 < 5.5
0.4
2003
G. N. Odvody
0
8.8 < 12.9 < 17.2
1.6
2.8 < 4.0 < 4.8
0.4
2003
G. N. Odvody
0
8.1 < 13.1 < 18.2
1.6
3.5 < 4.2 < 5.3
0.4
1982
V. French
0
9.6 < 14.1 < 24.8
1.9
3.4 < 4.3 < 5.4
0.4
0
9.1 < 12.5 < 16.6
1.5
2.2 < 3.5 < 4.5
0.4
1989
2000
D.E. Frederickson
0
15.6 < 19.9 < 25.2
2.2
2.9 < 5.2 < 5.7
0.5
2001
D.E. Frederickson
0
10.6 < 15.4 < 20.4
1.9
3.0 < 5.2 < 5.3
0.5
2001
D.E. Frederickson
0
10 < 14.3 < 20.7
1.7
3.6 < 4.5 < 6.1
0.6
2001
D.E. Frederickson
0
12.4 < 17.6 < 23.2
2.0
4.2 < 4.7 < 6.4
0.5
2001
D.E. Frederickson
0
12.5 < 18.1 < 24.8
2.1
4.1 < 5.6 < 6.3
0.9
Fungal Diversity
Table 3. Origin and identity of isolates used for DNA sequencing and alkaloid production.
Species
Specimen of
origin
Isolate
Host
Location
Year
Collector
Pennisetum sp.
Pennisetum typhoides
Pennisetum glaucum
Africa
French Central Africa
Shamva, Zimbabwe
1960’s
1957
1999
N.W. Mc Laren
Pennisetum glaucum
Eriochloa sericea
Gulbarga, Karnataka, India
Kingsville, Texas
2005
2006
R.H. Angadi
G. N. Odvody
Pennisetum glaucum
Pennisetum glaucum
Weslaco, Texas
Corpus Christi, Texas
2003
2003
G. N. Odvody
G. N. Odvody
EF052277
EF052278
EF052279
EF473873
EF473874
EF473878
Claviceps hirtella
PRM 857332
"
PRM 857333
PRM 857334
"
"
"
PRM 857337
PRM 857336
"
"
"
BRIP 43959
CCC 110 (F27)
CCC 106 (47A)
CCC 525
CCC 524
CCC 846
CCC 859
CCC863
CCC 868
CCC 872
CCC 774
CCC 776
CCC 778
CCC 777
CCC 858
CCC 786
Urochloa sp.
Goondiwindi, Queensland,
Australia
2004
R.G. Shivas, T.S. Marney
EF052280
EF473872
Sphacelia lovelessii
"
"
"
"
"
"
PRM 857340
CCC 792
CCC 787
CCC 788
CCC 789
CCC 790
CCC 791
CCC 642
PRM 857341
PRM 857339
CCC 646
CCC 647
CBS 125.63
Claviceps fusiformis
Sphacelia eriochloae
Sphacelia texensis
Claviceps viridis
Accession No.
rDNA
β-tubulin
EF052275 EF473876
AJ133392 AM498382
AJ626727 EF473867
“
EF473866
EF052276 EF473877
EF473864 EF473875
EF473871
Urochloa
mosambicensis
Urochloa oligotricha
Eragrostis sp.
Oplismenus compositus
Matopos, Zimbabwe
2001
D.E. Frederickson
EF052282
EF473870
Matopos, Zimbabwe
Matopos, Zimbabwe
India
2001
2001
D.E. Frederickson
D.E. Frederickson
EF052281
AJ605996
AJ133404
EF473869
EF473868
EF473865
99
Fig. 1. Neighbor-joining tree obtained from phylogenetic analysis of a combination of rDNA and partial β-tubulin
sequences with Claviceps viridis as an outgroup. Bootstrap confidence levels, based on 1000 replicates, are given on the
appropriate branches. Bootstrap values for maximum parsimony tree (with the same topology) are given in brackets.
Note that a recent C. fusiformis isolate from India (CCC 846) is more closely related to African isolates originating
from around 1960 (CCC 106, 110) than to recent African isolates (CCC 524, 525).
of Microbiology, Academy of Sciences of the
Czech Republic, Prague).
Media and cultivation
Isolates were maintained on T2 agar
slants by transfer every two months. For
alkaloid production, seed cultures in sucroseasparagine medium (TI) were inoculated with 3
ml of conidial suspension from a slant culture
and incubated for 10 days. Five ml of seed
culture were transferred to fermentation culture
(T2) and incubated for 20 - 29 days (Pažoutová
et al., 1981) The cultivations proceeded on a
rotary shaker at 24 oC in 250 ml Erlenmeyer
flasks with 60 ml of the respective medium.
Colony morphology was observed after 15
days of growth on T2 agar plate
Microscopy
Only honeydew specimens were used for
observation and measurement of conidial size
as conidia from cultures exhibit greater
100
variability in shape and size. Conidia were
stained in 1% cotton blue in lactic acid and
photographed and measured using an Olympus
BX51 microscope equipped with a digital
camera (CAMEDIA) and image-processing
software (QuickPHOTO Camera 2.2.). At least
50 conidia from each sample were measured.
Statistical analyses of spore size data were
performed using Kyplot 2.0 beta 15 (Yoshioka,
2002).
Alkaloid analysis
Cultures were centrifuged and in the suitably
diluted supernatant, the alkaloids were
measured colorimetrically using Van Urk’s
reagent (Pažoutová et al., 1981) with elymoclavine as a standard. For qualitative alkaloid
analysis, the culture was centrifuged; supernatant was alkalized with NH4OH to pH 8-9 and
twice extracted with the same volume of
dichloromethane. The extracts were combined
and dried using anhydrous Na2SO4, then
Fungal Diversity
evaporated to dryness and dissolved in 200 µl
of methanol. Alkaloid content was analyzed by
high performance liquid chromatography
(HPLC) (Pažoutová et al., 2000). Thin layer
chromatography (TLC) of alkaloids was
performed on silica gel plates (Merck) exposed
briefly to NH3 vapors, developed in
chloroform:methanol (8:2), and detected using
Ehrlich’s reagent spray.
search of the initial tree with a search factor 3
and random addition of trees with 60
repetitions. The stability of clades was evaluated by a bootstrap test with 1000 replications.
The dataset and analysis were archived in
TreeBase under the submission ID number
SN3321.
DNA preparation and analyses
DNA was purified from 4-7 days-old
mycelium grown on T2 plates overlaid with
cellophane using an UltraClean Microbial
DNA Isolation Kit (Mo-Bio Laboratories,
Solana Beach, California) according to the
manufacturer’s manual. Nuclear rDNA
containing internal transcribed spacers (ITS1
and ITS2), 5.8S and D1- D2 domains of the
28S region were amplified with primers ITS5
and NL4 (White et al., 1990). A region of the
β-tubulin gene containing part of intron 1,
introns 2, 3 and 4, exons 2, 3, 4 and the first 56
base pairs of exon 5 was obtained using
primers T1 and T22 (O'Donnell and Cigelnik,
1997). The reaction conditions in a Mastercycler Gradient thermocycler (Eppendorf,
Hamburg, Germany) were as follows: 1 cycle
of 3 minutes at 95°C, 30 seconds at 55°C and 1
minute at 72°C; 30 cycles of 30 seconds at
95°C, 30 seconds at 55°C and 1 minute at
72°C; 1 cycle 30 seconds at 95°C, 30 seconds
at 55°C and 10 minutes at 72°C. The reaction
mixture consisted of PCR buffer, 1U of
DynaZyme (both Finnzymes, Oy, Finland), 0.2
mM deoxynucleotides, 2 pmol of each primer,
and 5-50 ng of DNA in 25 µl of total volume.
Custom sequencing of DNA was done at
Macrogen Inc. (Seoul, Korea).
All infections sampled (Table 2) exhibitted the sphacelial stage of ergot development.
Honeydew production (fresh drops or a dried
crust on glumes) was the only sign of infection.
Sphacelia were still hidden in the glumes and
no mature sclerotia were found, except for the
pearl millet specimen from India. Attempts to
germinate these sclerotia into perithecial heads
were unsuccessful.
Phylogenetic analysis
Two sequence alignments were constructed: the datasets for rDNA and β-tubulin.
Sequences were aligned using MUSCLE
(Edgar, 2004) and the alignments were edited
with BioEdit (Hall, 1999). Phylogenetic analyses were performed using MEGA 3.1 (Kumar
et al., 2004). A neighbor-joining tree was
constructed using the Kimura-2 parameter
model with complete deletion option. A
maximum parsimony (MP) tree was computed
using close neighbor interchange, mini-heuristic
Results
Phylogenetic results
The dataset of rDNA sequences contained 1187 sites, yielding 22 variable positions
with 12 singletons and only 10 sites informative for parsimony. The dataset of partial βtubulin sequences contained 1554 sites with 60
variable positions, 36 of which were informative for parsimony. All mutations in the coding
regions of the β-tubulin gene were synonymous
at the third codon position. Both datasets were
combined and Claviceps viridis was added as
the outgroup. The topology of the distance tree
and consensus MP tree was identical (Fig. 1).
Parsimony analysis found 15 equally parsimonious trees, which differed only in the mutual
positions of C. fusiformis isolates from Africa
and India.
Two well-supported clades were found.
The fusiformis-hirtella clade comprised four
well-supported lineages with very small distances between sequences: the African and Indian
C. fusiformis isolates from pearl millet, a Texas
isolate from Eriochloa sericea, isolates from
pearl millet from the same area and C. hirtella
at the ancestral position. The second clade
consisted of African isolates from Urochloa
and Eragrostis.
Alkaloid production
Alkaloids in planta (Table 2) were only
detected in pearl millet florets containing
sphacelia and honeydew of C. fusiformis from
101
Fig. 2. Morphology of conidia from honeydew and colonies (reverse and obverse) on medium T2. a-c. Claviceps
fusiformis. d-f. Sphacelia eriochloae. g-i. Sphacelia texensis. j-l. Claviceps hirtella. m-o. Sphacelia lovelessii. Bars =
20 µm.
102
Fungal Diversity
Africa and India and in Eriochloa florets with
S. eriochloae from Texas.
All lineages defined by the phylogenetical analysis were also clearly distinguishable
by the specific qualitative combination of
alkaloids. In shaken cultures (Table 4), C.
fusiformis isolates from Africa and India
produced agroclavine and elymoclavine as
major alkaloids, accompanied by chanoclavine.
C. hirtella readily produced a whole range of
clavines with agroclavine and festuclavine
predominating, but ergometrine was also
detected. Of the Texas isolates, the isolate from
Eriochloa produced mainly agroclavine, elymoclavine and festuclavine and the cultures of
isolates from pearl millet contained small
amounts of agroclavine and festuclavine.
African isolates from Urochloa and Eragrostis
produced only traces of clavines on the
detection threshold limit.
Morphology
Colony morphology was observed on T2
agar, specifically suited for Claviceps growth
and secondary metabolite production (Fig. 2).
On widely-used fungal media such as maltextract agar (MEA) and Czapek-Dox (CZD),
culture growth is about half of that on T2 and
the typical pigmentation and structure of the
colonies is not expressed. Therefore, MEA and
CZD are unsuitable for morphological characterization of ergot fungi.
Colonies of C. fusiformis isolates from
pearl millet (Africa, India) and those from
Texas from Eriochloa and pearl millet were
similar (Fig. 2) on T2 agar. Typically, all
showed rapid growth (2-4.8 cm in 14d) with a
diffuse and markedly radiating margin. Colony
was mostly velutinous, consisting of highly
sporulating conidiophores, giving a powdery
appearance; raised with cerebriform wrinkles in
the centre and plane toward the margin;
obverse, off-white to grayish; reverse, similar
or slightly brown, typically turning reddish
brown with age in some strains of C. fusiformis
(CCC 525, CCC 846); soluble pigments
yellowish to reddish brown.
African isolates from Urochloa and
Eragrostis exhibited restricted growth ( < 1.5
cm) and absence of sporulation and pigment
production. In these isolates, conidiation ability
was lost during the first year of isolation,
whereas cultures of all the other isolates retained conidiation ability, sometimes for decades.
Conidia of C. fusiformis from Africa and
India (Table 2, Fig. 2) were long (mean 18.9
µm), mostly straight and fusiform. Conidia
from honeydew of Texas isolates from Eriochloa and pearl millet, and of C. hirtella, were
smaller (12 µm) and more lunate. Conidia from
African honeydew specimens from Urochloa
and Eragrostis were the same length as C.
fusiformis but slightly wider (5.2 µm; c.f. 4.8
µm C. fusiformis) and more lunate.
Taxonomy
All analyses reveal that the specimens
from Africa and India, determined traditionally
as C. fusiformis according to Loveless (1967),
represent a taxonomically homogenous group
with host specificity to Cenchrus and Pennisetum. Similarly, the Australian species C.
hirtella has a distinct position. Specimens with
fusiform conidia colonizing pearl millet and C.
ciliaris in Texas were closely related to C.
fusiformis, but showed distinct differential
characters in DNA sequence, conidia size and
alkaloid production; therefore this group is
described here as new species. Because there
was no teleomorph available (sphacelia were
mostly infected in the course of development
by Epicoccum andropogonis and did not
mature) and the International Code of Botanical Nomenclature does not allow the application of a teleomorph name in the absence of the
teleomorph (Greuter et al., 2000), the species
will be described as Sphacelia texensis. Also a
new name, Sphacelia eriochloae, is proposed
here for the fungus from Eriochloa because of
its unique combination of host specificity with
alkaloid and DNA characteristics.
African isolates from Urochloa and
Eragrostis differed from all other specimens in
all aspects and the new name S. lovelessii is
designated here for this new species.
Claviceps fusiformis Loveless, Transactions of
the British Mycological Society 50: 17. (1967)
(Fig. 2a,b,c )
Cultural characteristics: colonies on T2
medium, (14d, 24°C) 21-48 mm in diameter;
diffuse and markedly radiating margin, colony
mostly velutinous, consisting of highly sporulating conidiophores giving a powdery appearance,
103
Table 4 Alkaloid yield of Claviceps/Sphacelia isolates in shaken culture.
Claviceps fusiformis
Sphacelia eriochloae
Sphacelia texensis
Isolate CCC No. 524
525
106
110
846
859
863
868
872
774
776
777
Cultivation
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
29
29
29
(days)*)
Total alkaloids
1520 1050 1265 510
800
1280 7930 3780 5210 65
91
111
(mg.L-1)
Constituent
alkaloids (%):
Ergometrine
Elymoclavine
21
26.7
13.2
68
10.5 22.1
21.4
24.3
22.3
Chanoclavine
1.3
2.9
1.4
24
0.8
2
6.5
2
6.1
Chanoclavine-1- 0.7
2.9
aldehyde
DH-setoclavine
iso-DHsetoclavine
Agroclavine
75.7
68.5
80.3
8
70.6 41.4
34.4
30.1
40.8
17.1 17.5 34.7
Festuclavine
12.4
9.3
8.1
9.1
82.9 35.3 46.5
Pyroclavine
1.9
1.4
10.4
1.1
Lysergol, DH4.2
lysergol
unknown
1.31
1.9
2.1
14
20
27
25
20
0
47.2 18.8
clavines
*) Cultivations were terminated when viscosity due to glucan production rendered aeration ineffective
ND - not determined, alkaloid content too low to permit a qualitative analysis
104
778
29
858
29
98
117
8.4
27.1
55.2
44.8
64.5
0
Claviceps hirtella
786 787 788
27
24
24
789
29
790
24
791
24
792
27
Sphacelia lovelessii
645
646 649
29
29
29
247
2
971
1354
143
3
586
326
219
37
6.1
12.7
1.9
2.6
4.5
1.9
3.3
4.7
1.6
3.4
6.6
3
3.2
6.6
2.5
8.7
7.9
3.3
7.2
3.6
2.6
100
6.7
1
5.7
1.3
3.1
1.1
6.7
1.2
4.9
1.1
5.9
1.2
4.2
1.2
24
42.3
4.2
1
19.2
57.9
5.7
1.3
24.2
59.6
1.3
1.1
26.1
48.7
3
1.2
13.2
65
2.4
1.1
5.8
63.5
2.5
1.2
12.5
66.4
1.2
1.2
36
31
ND
100
ND
Fungal Diversity
raised with typically cerebriform wrinkles in
the centre and plane toward the margin, obverse
off-white to grayish, reverse similar or light
brown getting typically reddish brown in age in
some strains, soluble diffuse pigment yellowish
to reddish brown to vinaceous.
Macroconidia: fusiform, straight, rarely
lunate (10-28 × 3-9 µm, mean 19 × 5 µm).
Teleomorph: not examined, see Loveless
(1967) and Thakur et al.(1984).
Alkaloids: production in the culture:
spontaneous, high (500-2000 mg/L); main
alkaloids: chanoclavine, agroclavine, elymoclavine.
Habitat: in living florets of Pennisetum
and Cenchrus spp.
Known distribution: Africa, India.
Material examined: ZIMBABWE, Matopos, from
floret of Pennisetum glaucum 2001, D.E. Frederickson
(PRM 857331); Shamwa, from floret of Pennisetum
glaucum 2001, N. McLaren, (PRM 857332) (cultures
CCC524, 525); INDIA, Karnataka, Gulbarga, from floret
of Pennisetum glaucum 2005, R.H. Angadi, (PRM
857333) (culture CCC846).
Notes: Our concept of C. fusiformis
agrees with definition of Loveless (1967) and
Thakur et al.(1984). The species infects
typically species of Cenchrus and Pennisetum.
Long fusiform conidia which are rarely lunate
are also distinct.
Claviceps hirtella Langdon, Proceedings of the
Royal Society of Queensland 54: 27. (1942)
(Fig. 2j, k, l)
Cultural characteristics: colonies on T2
medium (14d, 24°C) from 25 mm to 38 mm in
diameter, obverse off-white, reverse with
shades of rose-grey. Two types of growth
occurred even in colonies of the same isolate.
Colonies growing more rapidly were more
diffuse on margin, markedly radiating,
velutinous and plane. Colonies with slower
growth consisted of dense mycelial mat.
Sporulation was absent in both cases.
Macroconidia: lunate to fusiform (9-25 ×
2-5.5 µm, mean 13 × 4 µm).
Teleomorph: not examined, see Langdon
(1942)
Alkaloids: production in the culture:
spontaneous, high (200-2500 mg/L); main
alkaloids: ergometrine, chanoclavine, setoclavine, elymoclavine, agroclavine, festuclavine.
Habitat: in living florets of Urochloa,
Cenchrus, Paspalidium, Eriochloa, and
Entolasia.
Known distribution: Australia.
Material
examined:
AUSTRALIA,
Qld,
Meandarra, in florets of Cenchrus ciliaris, 1982
(BRIP13544); AUSTRALIA, Qld, Blackall, in florets of
Cenchrus ciliaris, 1989 (BRIP16635); AUSTRALIA,
Qld, Goondiwindi, in florets of Urochloa sp., 2004
(BRIP 43959) (cultures CCC786-CCC792).
Notes: The typical differential character
of this species is the production of ergometrine.
Sphacelia eriochloae Pažoutová & Odvody sp.
nov.
(Fig. 2d, e, f)
Etymology: Referring to the host plant name.
Hab. in ovariis et in inflorescentiis Eriochloae
sericeis, Texas
Species similis Claviceps fusiformis sed differt
per suam combinationem characterum; macroconidiis
hyaliniis, fusoideis vel lunatis (6.7-15.7 × 2.5-5.5 µm,
mediet. 11.6 × 3.6 µm); regio ‘rDNA ITS’, ‘rDNA28S
cum polymorphismis unicis sequentiae (GenBank
EF473864). Teleomorphosis ignota.
Cultural characteristics: colonies on T2
medium (14d, 24°C) 21-26 mm in diameter,
like C. fusiformis.
Macroconidia: lunate to fusiform (6.715.7 × 2.5-5.5 µm, mean. 11.6 × 3.6 µm)
Teleomorph: not observed.
Alkaloids:
production
in
culture:
spontaneous, very high (2000-8000 mg/L);
main alkaloids: chanoclavine, festuclavine,
elymoclavine, agroclavine.
Habitat: in living florets of Eriochloa
sericea
Known distribution: Texas, Mexico.
Material examined: TEXAS, Agua Dulce, in
florets of Eriochloa sericea, 1997, G.N. Odvody (PRM
857335); TEXAS, Kingsville, in florets of Eriochloa
sericea, 2006, G.N. Odvody (HOLOTYPE, PRM
857334) (ex type culture CCC859), Mycobank
Accession No.: MB 510710
Molecular characters: sequence of the
ITS and D1D2 regions of the 28S rDNA
unique (EF473864). The sequence is given in
the format [three-prime 18S]ITS1*5.8S*ITS2
[five-prime 28S].
[ATCATTA]CCGAGTTTTCAACTCCCAAAC
CCACTGTGAACCTATACCAAAAACGTTGCCTCG
GCGGGACATGCGCCCCGGACCGCCCCCCCCCCT
CGCGGGGGAGGGCGCCGGATCCCACGGCCGCCC
GCCGGGGGCCCCAAACTCTGTATTCCCATAGCG
GCATGTCTGAGTGGATTTATCCAATAAATCA*AA
ACTTTCAACAACGGATCTCTTGGTTCTGGCATCG
ATGAAGAACGCAGCGAAATGCGATAAGTAATGT
GAATTGCAGAATTCAGTGAATCATCGAATCTTT
GAACGCACATTGCGCCCGCCAGTACTCTGGCGG
105
GCATGCCTGTTCGAGCGTCATT*TCAACCCTCAG
GCCCCCGGGCCTGGTGTTGGGGACCGGCTCACG
GGGGGGAGGCACAGCGCCCCCCCCCCCTGCCGC
CCCCTAAATGGATCGGCGGCCACGCCGCGGCCT
CCCCTGCGCAGTAACATACCACCTCGCAGGCGG
CTGGCTCGGCGCGGCCACTGCCGTAAAACGCCC
AACTTCTCCAGAG[TTGACCTCGAATCAGGTAGG
AATACCCGCTGAACTTAAGCATATCAATAAGCG
GAGGAAAAGAAACCAACAGGGATTGCCCCAGT
AACGGCGAGTGAAGCGGCAACAGCTCAAATTTG
AAATCTGGCCCCCCGGGGCCCGAGTTGTAATTT
GCAGAGGATGCTTTTGGCGAGGCGCCTTCCGAG
TTCCCTGGAACGGGACGCCATAGAGGGTGAGAG
CCCCGTCTGGTCGGACGCCGAGCCTCTGTAAAG
CTCCTTCGACGAGTCGAGTAGTTTGGGAATGCT
GCTCTAAATGGGAGGTATATGTCTTCTAAAGCT
AAATACCGGCCAGAGACCGATAGCGCACAAGT
AGAGTGATCGAAAGATGAAAAGCACTTTGAAA
AGAGGGTTAAACAGTACGTGAAATTGTTGAAAG
GGAAGCGCCTGTGACCAGACTTGCGCCCGTCGG
ATCACCCAGCGTTCTCGCTGGTGCACTCCGGCG
GGCGCAGGCCAGCATCAGCTCGTCTCGGGGGAC
AAAGGCGGCGGGAACGTGGCTCCTCCGGGAGTG
TTATAGCCCGCCGTGCAATGCCCTGGGGCGGGC
TGAGGACCGCGCGTAAGCATGGATGCTGGCGTA
ATGGTCATCAGCGACCCGTCTTGAAACACGGAC
CAA].
Notes: The species has smaller conidia
than C. fusiformis, C. hirtella or S. lovelessii.
The only ergot fungus with similar conidia
occurring in Texas is Sphacelia texensis, from
which it differs in host, DNA sequences, and
high overall production of alkaloids.
Sphacelia texensis Pažoutová & Odvody sp.
nov.
(Fig. 2g, h, i)
Etymology: Named after the geographical origin
Hab. in ovariis et in inflorescentiis Penniseti
glauci et Cenchri ciliari, Texas.
Claviceps fusiformis var. texensis differt per suam
combinationem characterum; macroconidiis hyaliniis,
fusoideis vel lunatis (7-19 × 2.8-5.5 µm, mediet.12.5 × 4
µm); regio ‘rDNA ITS’, ‘rDNA28S cum polymorphismis unicis sequentiae (GenBank EF052277,
EF052278 et EF052279). Teleomorphosis ignota.
Cultural characteristics: colonies on T2
medium (14d, 24°C) from 35 mm to 53 mm in
diameter, margin diffuse and markedly radiating, colony granular, velutinous, consisting of
numerous conidiophores, raised with cerebriform wrinkles in the centre and plane toward
the margin, obverse off-white, reverse similar
or with shades of brown, soluble pigment
slightly yellow.
Macroconidia: lunate to fusiform (7-19 ×
2.8-5.5 µm, mean 12.5 × 4 µm).
Teleomorph: Claviceps sp. (not seen,
based on phylogenetic inferences).
106
Alkaloids: production in the culture:
spontaneous, low (≤ 100 mg/L); main alkaloids: agroclavine, festuclavine.
Habitat: in living florets of Pennisetum
glaucum and Cenchrus ciliaris.
Known distribution: Texas.
Material examined: TEXAS, Agua Dulce, in
florets of Cenchrus ciliaris, 1997; TEXAS, Kenedy
county, in florets of Cenchrus ciliaris, 1997 (PRM
857338); TEXAS, Weslaco, in florets of Pennisetum
glaucum, 1998, G.N. Odvody; TEXAS, Weslaco, in
florets of Pennisetum glaucum, 2003, G.N. Odvody
(PRM 857337); TEXAS, Corpus Christi, in florets of
Pennisetum glaucum, 2003, G.N. Odvody (HOLOTYPE, PRM 857336) (culture CCC858), Mycobank
Accession No.: MB 510709
Molecular characters: sequences of the
ITS and D1D2 regions of the 28S rDNA
unique (EF052277, EF052278 et EF052279).
The consensus sequence is given in the format
[three-prime 18S]ITS1*5.8S*ITS2 [five-prime
28S].
[ATCATTA]CCGAGTTTTCAACTCCCAAAC
CCACTGTGAACCTATACCAAAAACGTTGCCTCG
GCGGGACATGCGCCCCGGACCGCCCCCCCCTCG
CGGGGGAGGGCGCCGGATCCCACGGCCGCCCGC
CGGGGGCCCCAAACTCTGTATTCCCATAGCGGC
ATGTCTGAGTGGATTTATCCAATGAATCA*AAAC
TTTCAACAACGGATCTCTTGGTTCTGGCATCGAT
GAAGAACGCAGCGAAATGCGATAAGTAATGTG
AATTGCAGAATTCAGTGAATCATCGAATCTTTG
AACGCACATTGCGCCCGCCAGTACTCTGGCGGG
CATGCCTGTTCGAGCGTCATT*TCAACCCTCAGG
CCCCCGGGCCTGGTGTTGGGGACCGGCTCACGG
GGGGGAGGCACAGCGCCCTCCCCCCCTGCCGCC
CCCTAAATGGATCGGCGGCCACGCCGCGGCCTC
CCCTGCGCAGTAACATACCACCTCGCAGGCGGC
TGGCTCGGCGCGGCCACTGCCGTAAAACGCCCA
ACTTCTCCAGAG[TTGACCTCGAATCAGGTAGGA
ATACCCGCTGAACTTAAGCATATCAATAAGCGG
AGGAAAAGAAACCAACAGGGATTGCCCCAGTA
ACGGCGAGTGAAGCGGCAACAGCTCAAATTTGA
AATCTGGCCCCCCGGGGCCCGAGTTGTAATTTG
CAGAGGATGCTTTTGGCGAGGCGCCTTCCGAGT
TCCCTGGAACGGGACGCCATAGAGGGTGAGAGC
CCCGTCTGGTCGGACGCCGAGCCTCTGTAAAGC
TCCTTCGACGAGTCGAGTAGTTTGGGAATGCTG
CTCTAAATGGGAGGTATATGTCTTCTAAAGCTA
AATACCGGCCAGAGACCGATAGCGCACAAGTA
GAGTGATCGAAAGATGAAAAGCACTTTGAAAA
GAGGGTTAAACAGTACGTGAAATTGTTGAAAGG
GAAGCGCCTGTGACCAGACTTGCGCCCGTCGGA
TCACCCAGCGTTCTCGCTGGTGCACTCCGGCGG
GCGCAGGCCAGCATCAGCTCGTCTCGGGGGACA
AAGGCGGCGGGAACGTGGCTCCTCCGGGAGTGT
TATAGCCCGCCGCGCAATGCCCTGGGGCGGGCT
GAGGACCGCGCGTAAGCATGGATGCTGGCGTAA
TGGTCATCAGCGACCCGTCTTGAAACACGGACC
AA]
Fungal Diversity
Notes: Sphacelia texensis differs from
Claviceps fusiformis and C. hirtella by
combination of characters: smaller conidial
dimensions and low alkaloid production in
vitro and in planta. Sequence of the ITS, D1D2
regions of the 28S rDNA (EF052277,
EF052278 and EF052279) and β–tubulin are
unique and identical (EF473873, EF473874
and EF473878); next nearest known relatives
being S. eriochloae and C. hirtella.
Sphacelia lovelessii Pažoutová, M. Kola ík &
Freder. sp. nov.
(Fig. 2m, n, o)
Etymology: Named after A.R. Loveless (British
mycologist).
Hab. in ovariis et in inflorescentiis Urochloae
spp. et Eragrostidis sp., Zimbabwe.
Sphacelia lovelessii differt ab aliis speciebus per
suam combinationem characterum; macroconidiis hyaliniis, lunatis vel fusioideis (10-25 × 3-6.4 µm, mediet.17
× 5 µm); regio ‘rDNA ITS’, ‘rDNA28S cum polymorphismis unicis sequentiae (EF052282, EF052281,
AJ605996). Teleomorphosis ignota.
Cultural characteristics: colonies on T2
medium (14d, 24°C) from 15mm (CCC 642,
646) to 27 mm (CCC 647) in diameter, margin
narrow or lobate, colony plane (CCC 647) or
raised centrally and wrinkled (CCC 642, 646)
consisting of dense myceliar mat, sporulation
absent, obverse white, reverse off-white to
slightly brown in the centre similar or with
shades of brown, soluble pigment absent.
Macroconidia: lunate (10-25 × 3-6.4 µm,
mean 17 × 5 µm).
Teleomorph: Claviceps sp. (based on
phylogenetic inferences but unknown)
Alkaloids: traces of chanoclavine or
agroclavine.
Habitat: in living florets of Urochloa
spp.,and Eragrostis sp.
Known distribution: Zimbabwe.
Material examined: ZIMBABWE, Matopos, in
florets of Urochloa sp., 2000, D.E. Frederickson;
ZIMBABWE, Matopos (PRM 857342); in florets of
Urochloa mosambicensis, 2001, D.E. Frederickson
(PRM 857340) (culture CCC642); ZIMBABWE,
Matopos, in florets of Urochloa oligotricha, 2001, D.E.
Frederickson (culture CCC646); ZIMBABWE, Matopos,
in florets of Urochloa trichopus, 2001, D.E.
Frederickson; ZIMBABWE, Matopos, in florets of
Eragrostis sp., 2001, D.E. Frederickson (HOLOTYPE,
PRM 857340) (culture CCC648). Mycobank Accession
No.: MB 510615
Molecular characters: sequences of the
ITS and D1D2 regions of the 28S rDNA
unique (EF052282, EF052281, AJ605996).
The consensus sequence is given in the format
[three-prime 18S]ITS1*5.8S*ITS2[five-prime
28S]. Nucleotides in bold indicate differences
among the sequences: underlined – transitions/transversions; bracketed – not present in
all sequences.
[ATCATTA]CCGAGTTTTCAACTCCCAAAC
CCACTGTGAACCCGTACCAAAAACGTTGCCTCG
GCGGGAGATGCGCCCCGGACCGCCCCCCCCC(C
C)TCGCGGGGGAGGGCGCCGGATCCCACGGCCG
CCCGCCGGGGGCCCCAAACTCTGTATTCCCATA
GCGGCATGTCTGAGTGGATTTATCCAATGAATC
A*AAACTTTCAACAACGGATCTCTTGGTTCTGGC
ATCGATGAAGAACGCAGCGAAATGCGATAAGT
AATGTGAATTGCAGAATTCAGTGAATCATCGAA
TCTTTGAACGCACATTGCGCCCGCCAGTACTCTG
GCGGGCATGCCTGTTCGAGCGTCATT*TCAACCC
TCAGGCCCCCGGGCCTGGTGTTGGGGACCGGCT
CACGGGGGG(G)R(CA)ACAGCGCCCSCCCTGCCG
CCCCCTAAATGGATCGGCGGCCACGCCGCGGCC
TCCC(C)TGCGCAGTAACATACCACCTCGCAGGC
GGCTGGCTCGGCGCGGCCACTGCCGYAAAACGC
CCAACTTCTCAAGAG[TTGACCTCGAATCAGGTA
GGAATACCCGCTGAACTTAAGCATATCAATAAG
CGGAGGAAAAGAAACCAACAGGGATTGCCCCA
GTAACGGCGAGTGAAGCGGCAACAGCTCAAATT
TGAAATCTGGCCCCCCGGGGCCCGAGTTGTAAT
TTGCAGAGGATGCTTTTGGCGAGGCGCCTTCCSA
GTTCCCTGGAACGGGACGCCATAGAGGGTGAGA
GCCCCGTCTGGTCGGACGCCGAGCCTCTGTAAA
GCTCCTTCGACGAGTCGAGTAGTTTGGGAATGC
TGCTCTAAATGGGAGGTATATGTCTTCTAAAGCT
AAATACCGGCCAGAGACCGATAGCGCACAAGT
AGAGTGATCGAAAGATGAAAAGCACTTTGAAA
AGAGGGTTAAACAGTACGTGAAATTGTTGAAAG
GGAAGCGCCTGTGACCAGACTTGCGCCCGCCGG
ATCACCCAGCGTTCTCGCTGGTGCACTCCGGCG
GGCACAGGCCAGCATCAGCTCGTCTCGGGGGAC
AAAGGCGGCGGGAACGTGGCTCCTCCGGGAGTG
TTATAGCCCGCCGTGCAATGCCCTGGGGCGGGC
TGAGGACCGCGCGTACGCATGGATGCTGGCGTA
ATGGTCATCAGCGACCCGTCTTGAAACACGGAC
CAA].
Notes: Sphacelia lovelessii differs from
Claviceps fusiformis by markedly lunate
conidia. It differs from C. fusiformis, C.
hirtella, S. eriochloae and S. texensis by
absence of alkaloids in vitro and in planta and
by lack of conidiation and slow and compact
growth on agar medium T2.
Discussion
DNA and alkaloid analyses now confirm
the hypothesis of an introduction of C.
fusiformis to India from Africa, since the
Indian isolate was very similar to African
isolates, especially to those collected around
1960. Whereas C. fusiformis, appearing as a
107
clade terminal on the phylogram, is a known
parasite of Cenchrus and Pennisetum spp.,
ancestral C. hirtella was collected from a
broader range of native hosts. The first record
of C. hirtella on Cenchrus ciliaris is from 1976
(BRIP 11355), although this grass was
introduced to Australia around 1870. The
occurrence of diverging populations from
Pennisetum, Cenchrus and Eriochloa show
that, in common with species complexes of
other phytopathogenic fungi (Crous and
Groenewald, 2005), evolution has been
towards narrower host preferences.
In southern India, honeydew specimens
containing lunate conidia were observed on
various host grasses many years before C.
fusiformis was introduced. At that time, neither
large-scale epiphytotics of disease on pearl
millet nor alkaloid toxicoses of grazing animals
were recorded. Langdon (1952) suspected that
the Indian records prior to 1950 might refer to
C. hirtella or a closely related fungus.
However, the descriptions of conidia on the
Indian grass specimens as long (Table 1) are
more consistent with S. lovelessii, which also
does not produce any alkaloids. Unfortunately,
no Indian isolates or specimens from hosts
other than pearl millet are available for
comparison with the other fungi of the C.
fusiformis species complex.
Members of the C. fusiformis species
complex also differ in their alkaloid biosynthesis gene cluster. In the ”standard” biosynthetic pathway, elymoclavine (C-17 hydroxyagroclavine) is an end product of the clavine
pathway that may be further oxidized to Dlysergic acid and its amides e.g. ergometrine,
containing a simple amino alcohol as the amide
component (for review see Flieger et al., 1997).
In C. fusiformis, Lorenz et al. (2007) found that
the oxidation of clavines to lysergic acid is
inhibited because the respective clavine
oxidase gene, cloA, is inactive. Therefore, it
seems that ergometrine-producing C. hirtella
still possesses a functional gene that is missing
in all other members of the fusiformis-hirtella
clade. Due to only trace amounts of alkaloids
being produced by S. lovelessii (Table 4),
production of ergometrine in this species could
be neither proved nor disproved.
From the whole species complex, only C.
fusiformis and S. eriochloae have the potential
108
to cause human and/or animal toxicoses as they
are able to produce alkaloids in planta even in
the sphacelial stage of development.
The origin of ergot infections on pearl
millet, Cenchrus, and Eriochloa in Mexico and
Texas (San Martín et al., 1997; VelásquezValle et al., 1998) is rather unclear. In the
survey by Alderman et al. (2004) no records
for grasses with lunate or fusiform conidial
infections were mentioned. The presented
results clearly preclude C. fusiformis from
Africa or India as the causative pathogen. The
close genetic similarity of S. texensis to
Paleotropic C. fusiformis and C. hirtella,
however, suggests that S. texensis may be yet
another introduction from the Paleotropics
(Africa and Southeast Asia) to the Americas,
possibly with grass seed.
The presence of S. lovelessii in Zimbabwe represents another puzzle. Differences in
conidial shape and size as well as in DNA
markers among the isolates and specimens
suggest considerable infraspecific variability. It
is also the only Claviceps/Sphacelia species
with markedly lunate macroconidia to be
recorded in Africa – C. fusiformis tends to
straight, fusiform conidia. The older studies of
herbarium specimens and collections from
southern and eastern Africa (Doidge, 1950;
Langdon, 1952; Loveless, 1964a, b; Herd and
Loveless, 1965; Loveless, 1965) were
extensive and it is surprising that, at least until
collections stopped in the late 1960’s,
infections with the fusiform to lunate conidial
shape occurring on a grass genus as common
and widely distributed as Urochloa were
overlooked. However, only Claviceps sulcata
with allantoid conidia was reported (Loveless,
1964a; Loveless and Herd, 1964). Therefore, it
may be that infection with S. lovelessii is rather
rare. In contrast, the signs of ergot infection on
the tiny florets of Eragrostis, another widely
distributed
grass
genus,
were
very
inconspicuous and may easily have gone
unnoticed.
A polygeneric host range has been
documented not only in S. lovelessii (although
here it is even switching between host tribes),
but also in C. sorghi (Sorghum – Heteropogon;
Pažoutová et al., 2002) and C. africana
(Sorghum – Hyparrhenia; Pažoutová and Frederickson, 2005) which contradicts the original
Fungal Diversity
paradigm of “one Claviceps species – one host
genus” or at least “a group of closely related
host genera”. From the evolutionary point of
view, the less rigid host specificity may enable
the parasite to colonize alternative hosts after
migration to another region as a first step
towards adaptive radiation.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the Czech
Institutional Research Concept No. AV0Z5020903 and
by the International Sorghum/Millet Collaborative
Research Program (INTSORMIL).
References
Adyanthaya, N.R. (1946). A note on the occurrence of
Sphacelia on Cenchrus ciliaris. Current Science
15: 286-287.
Alderman, S.C., Halse, R.R. and White, J.F. (2004). A
reevaluation of the host range and geographical
distribution of Claviceps species in the United
States. Plant Disease 88: 63-81.
Banks, G.T., Mantle, P.G. and Szczyrbak, C.A. (1974).
Large-scale production of clavine alkaloids by
Claviceps fusiformis. Journal of General Microbiology 82: 345-361.
Bhat, R.V., Roy, D.N. and Tulpule, P.G. (1976). Nature
of alkaloids of ergoty pearl millet or bajra and its
comparison with alkaloids of ergoty rye and
ergoty wheat. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology 36: 11-17.
Bhide, V.P. and Hegde, R.K. (1957). Ergot on bajri
[Pennisetum typhoides (Burm.) Stapf and
Hubbard] in Bombay state. Current Science 26:
116.
Craig, J. and Hignight, K.W. (1991). Control of ergot in
buffelgrass with triadimefon. Plant Disease 75:
627-629.
Crous, P.W. and Groenewald, J.Z. (2005). Hosts, species
and genotypes: opinions versus data. Presented as
a Keynote Address at the 15th Biennial Conference of the Australasian Plant Pathology Society,
Geelong, Australia, 26-29 September 2005.
Australasian Plant Pathology 34: 463-470.
Doidge, E.M. (1950). The South African fungi and
lichens to the end of 1945. Bothalia 5: 1-1094.
Edgar, R.C. (2004). MUSCLE: multiple sequence alignment with high accuracy and high throughput.
Nucleic Acids Research 32: 1792-1797.
Flieger, M., Wurst, M. and Shelby, R. (1997). Ergot
Alkaloids - Sources, Structures and Analytical
Methods. Folia Microbiologica 42: 3-30.
Frederickson, D.E. (1990). Ergot disease of Sorghum.
PhD thesis, University of London, London.
Frederickson, D.E., Mantle, P.G. and De Milliano,
W.A.J. (1991). Claviceps africana sp. nov.; the
distinctive ergot pathogen of sorghum in Africa.
Mycological Research 95: 1101-1107.
Greuter, W., McNeill, J., Barre, F.R., Burdet, H.M.,
Demoulin, V., Filgueiras, T.S., Nicolson, D.H.,
Silva, P.C., Skog, J.E., Trehane, P., Turland, N.J.
and Hawksworth, D.L. (2000). International
Code of Botanical Nomenclature (St Louis Code)
Regnum Vegetabile138. Koeltz Scientific Books,
Königstein.
Hall, T.A. (1999). BioEdit: a user-friendly biological
sequence alignment editor and analysis program
for Windows 95/98/NT. Nucleic Acids
Symposium Series 41: 95-98.
Herd, G. and Loveless, A. (1965). Studies of Rhodesian
ergots. III. Claviceps rhynchelytri sp. nov. and
Claviceps digitariae Hansford. . Kirkia 5: 21-24.
Janardhanan, K.K., Singh, H.N. and Husain, A. (1982).
Studies on Claviceps parasitic on Panicum
species in India. Folia Microbiologica 27: 121125.
Kumar, A. and Arya, H.C. (1978). Estimation and
identification of alkaloids produced by Claviceps
fusiformis Loveless on some varieties of pearl
millet. Current Science 47: 633-635.
Kumar, S., Tamura, K. and Nei, M. (2004). MEGA3:
Integrated software for molecular evolutionary
genetics analysis and sequence alignment. Briefings in Bioinformatics 5: 150-163.
Langdon, R.F.N. (1942). Ergots on native grasses in
Queensland. Proceedings of the Royal Society
Queensland 54: 23-32.
Langdon, R.F.N. (1952). Studies on ergot. PhD. thesis,
University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia.
Lorenz, N., Wilson, E.V., Machado, C., Schardl, C.L.
and Tudzynski, P. (2007). Comparison of ergot
alkaloid biosynthesis gene clusters in Claviceps
species indicates loss of late pathway steps in
evolution of C. fusiformis. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 73: 7185-7191.
Loveless, A. (1967). Claviceps fusiformis sp. nov., the
causal agent of agalactia of sows. Transactions of
the British Mycological Society 50: 13-18.
Loveless, A.R. (1964a). Use of the honeydew state in the
identification of ergot species. Transactions of the
British Mycological Society 47: 205-213.
Loveless, A.R. (1964b). Studies of Rhodesian ergots 1.
Claviceps maximensis Theis and Claviceps
pusilla Cesati. Kirkia 4: 35-40.
Loveless, A.R. and Herd, G.W. (1964). Studies of
Rhodesian ergots. II. A redescription of Claviceps
sulcata Langdon. Kirkia 4: 41-43.
Loveless, A.R. (1965). Studies on Rhodesian ergots 4.
Claviceps cynodontis Langdon. Kirkia 5: 25-29.
O'Donnell, K. and Cigelnik, E. (1997). Two divergent
intragenomic rDNA ITS2 types within a monophyletic lineage of the fungus Fusarium are
nonorthologous. Molecular Phylogenetics and
Evolution 7: 103-116.
Pažoutová, S., Taisinger, J., Flieger, M., Sajdl, P., Bass,
A. and eháček, Z. (1981). The relationship
between intensity of oxidative metabolism and
predominance of agroclavine or elymoclavine in
submerged Claviceps purpurea cultures. Journal
of Natural Products 44: 225-235.
109
Pažoutová, S. and Tudzynski, P. (1999). Claviceps sp.
PRL 1980 (ATCC 26245), 59 and Pepty 695/ch-I:
their true story. Mycological Research 103: 10441048.
Pažoutová, S., Olšovská, J., Linka, M., Kolínská, R. and
Flieger, M. (2000). Chemoraces and habitat
specialization of Claviceps purpurea populations.
Applied and Environmental Microbiology 66:
5419-5425.
Pažoutová, S. (2001). The phylogeny and evolution of
the genus Claviceps. Mycological Research 105:
275-283.
Pažoutová, S. and Frederickson, D.E. (2005). Genetic
diversity of Claviceps africana on sorghum and
Hyparrhenia. Plant Pathology 54: 749-763.
Ramakrishnan, T.S. (1937). Some observations on
Sphacelia spp. occurring in Coimbatore. The
Madras Agricultural Journal 25: 119-121.
Ramakrishnan, T.S. (1947). The natural occurrence of
ergot in south India - III. Proceedings of the
Indian Academy of Sciences - B 26: 136-141.
San Martín, F., Lavín, P., García, A. and García, G.
(1997). Estados anamórficos de Claviceps
africana y Claviceps fusiformis (Ascomycetes,
Clavicipitaceae) asociados a diferentes pastos en
Tamaulipás, México. Revista Mexicana de
Micología 13: 52-57.
Shinde, P.A. and Bhide, V.P. (1958). Ergot of bajri
(Pennisetum typhoides) in Bombay state. Current
Science 27: 499-500.
Siddiqui, M.R. and Khan, I.D. (1973). Renaming
Claviceps microcephala ergot fungus on Pennisetum typhoides in India as Claviceps fusiformis.
Transactions of the Mycological Society of Japan
144: 195-198.
Singh, H.N. and Husain, A. (1977). Saprophytic production of ergot alkaloids by bajra ergot (Claviceps
fusiformis Loveless). Indian Journal of Experimental Biology 15: 585-586.
Sundaram, N.V., Bhowmik, T.P. and Khan, I.D. (1969).
A new host for Claviceps microcephala (Wallr.)
Tul. . Indian Journal of Agricultural Sciences 39:
703-705.
110
Thakur, D.P. and Kanwar, Z.S. (1978). Ability of
naturally incident Claviceps microcephala from
Panicum antidotale to produce ergot symptoms in
Pennisetum typhoides. Indian Journal of Agricultural Sciences 48: 540-542.
Thakur, R.P., Rao, V.P. and Williams, R.J. (1984). The
morphology and disease cycle of ergot caused by
Claviceps fusiformis in pearl millet. Phytopathology 74: 201-205.
Thirumalachar, M.J. (1945). Ergot and sphacelial stages
on some wild grasses in Mysore. Current Science
14: 22.
Thomas, K.M., Ramakrishnan, T.S. and Srinivasan, K.V.
(1945a). The natural occurrence of ergot in south
India - II. Proceedings of the Indian Academy of
Sciences - B 22: 191-192.
Thomas, K.M., Ramakrishnan, T.S. and Srinivasan, K.V.
(1945b). The natural occurrence of ergot in south
India. Proceedings of the Indian Academy of
Sciences - B 21: 93-100.
Tyler, V.E., Jr. (1958). Some factors influencing
saprophytic production of clavine alkaloids by
Claviceps purpurea. Journal of American
Pharmaceutical Association Sri. Ed. 47: 787-792.
Velásquez-Valle, R., San Martín, F., Odvody, G.N.,
Isakeit, T., Narro-Sánchez, J. and Mora-Nolasco,
R. (1998). Reporte preliminar sobre especies del
género Claviceps asociadas con pastos en algunos
estados de México y Texas, EUA. Revista
Mexicana de Fitopatología 16: 42-45.
White, T.J., Bruns, T., Lee, S. and Taylor, J. (1990).
Amplification and direct sequencing of fungal
ribosomal RNA genes for phylogenetics. In: PCR
Protocols: A Guide to Methods and Applications
(eds. M.A. Innis, D.H. Gelfand, J.J. Sninsky and
T.J. White). Academic Press, San Diego: 315322.
Yoshioka, K. (2002). KyPlot - a user-oriented tool for
statistical data analysis and visualization.
Computational Statistics 17: 425-437.
Fungal Diversity
111