Woman, 31, 'killed her live-in boyfriend with her mom's help and kept his body in a bin on their porch for months before dumping it in the woods' 

  • Erika Guttilla, 31, arrested on Tuesday accused of shooting 35-year-old Troy Ford
  • Said to have shot him in head then put corpse in a rug with mother Carmen's help
  • Pair said to have dumped body in a bin which was too full to put the lid back on
  • Remains of Troy Ford, 35, were found in abandoned playground by dog walkers
  • Companion of Ford said Erika showed him body and bloodstains in the bedroom

A Vermont woman was charged on Tuesday with murdering her live-in boyfriend with the help of her mother last fall and keeping his corpse in a trash bin on the porch for months before dumping it in the woods.

Erika Guttilla, 31, is accused of shooting 35-year-old Troy Ford after he fell asleep drunk before rolling the body in a rug with the aid of her mother, Carmen, 60, and stuffing it head-first into the bin, which was too full to put the lid back on.

ADVERTISEMENT

Carmen told detectives she and her daughter, from Sheldon, had decided to kill Ford after he had been physically abusing both of them for two years so they felt like 'hostages' in their own home, according to court documents.

Erika Guttilla
Carmen Guttilla

The alleged murder took place one night in November last year, and saw Carmen hand Erika a gun before the daughter shot her boyfriend in the head, the affidavit obtained by the Burlington Free Press states.

The body was bundled onto the porch outside the home, which Erika's parents owned, and left for several months before being dumped at a later date.  

The remains of Ford, who was originally from Brooklyn, were found on Saturday at an abandoned woodland playground near the Guttilla home by a pair of women walking their dogs. He had never been reported missing.

After the discovery, Erika went on the run with a male companion, Corey Cassani, 28, who she had been dating since January. 

They were arrested in a red Chevrolet Spark after a traffic stop.

Cassani is not suspected of involvement in the murder but could face charges for helping Erika attempt to evade justice.

Erika in an earlier police mug shot
Corey Cassani, 28, who is accused of helping her attempt to evade justice
Carmen appeared in court on Tuesday where she pleaded not guilty to first degree murder

Carmen, meanwhile, visited her husband in hospital before handing herself over to police. 

She was charged with first degree murder but pleaded not guilty at Vermont Superior Court in Burlington on Tuesday.

Documents lodged at the court describe an interview with prison inmate Edward Bennett, a companion of Ford who was arrested probation violation while out driving with Erick and Cassani last month.

ADVERTISEMENT

Speaking from Northwest State Correctional Facility on April 12, Bennett claimed to have been show Ford's body by Erika, who he said commented 'I killed him'.

The remains of Ford, who was originally from Brooklyn, were found on Saturday at an abandoned woodland playground near the Guttilla home
Police have cornered off the scene where the remains were discovered by a pair of women dog walkers

Erika then said she would bring him to live if it allowed her to kill him again, Bennett claimed.

She then took Bennet into her bedroom to show him a blood stain on the bed, explaining she had not cleared it up because she 'didn't care' because of the abuse he had inflicted on her.

Erika's sister and brother backed up her claims of abuse when interviewed by police, and said Ford would regularly conduct drug deals in the house. 

The red Chevrolet Spark that Erika Guttilla and Corey Cassani were driving when they were arrested on Tuesday 

Most Read News

Mother throws her disabled six-year-old son into a crocodile-infested river where he is 'mauled to...

Prince Harry WON'T meet Charles on whistle-stop UK trip due to King's 'full programme' but says 'I...

Prolific burglar, 44, caught breaking into M&S to steal steak and prosecco is the first to be jailed...

Five-month-old baby who suffered a cardiac arrest at Legoland Windsor dies after three days in...

Tens of millions of household savings and retirement nest eggs in jeopardy: Investment expert warns...

Our new-build homes flood every time it rains - because developers forgot to add drains! Residents...

Victim of road-rage driver, 60, who went viral screaming abuse at her outside a Tesco says ' I don't...

'I love Gaza' sign is crushed under armoured vehicle as Israel takes control of Rafah crossing in...

REVEALED: The full list of celebrities who have admitted to taking Ozempic - and what it did to...

World holds its breath as Israel tanks roll on Rafah: Jerusalem vows vast new ground invasion after...

'Samurai sword-wielding killer' Marcus Monzo 'essentially decapitated' schoolboy Daniel Anjorin, 14,...

Missing British father, 65, is found alive days after disappearing in Thailand during solo...

'China' hacks bank details of 250,000 British MOD workers: Beijing blamed as soldiers, veterans and...

The £100m Somerset public schoolboy with no GCSEs (but a string of glamorous admirers) who's...

The 1% Club contestant, 52, dies after filming: Fans of ITV quiz pay tribute to Steven Wong after...

How could the Greens NOT know about councillor's vile rant against a rabbi? Party faces fury for...