Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to navigation
Ethnic minority pupils during an English lesson at a primary school in Southall, London.
Ethnic minority pupils during an English lesson at a primary school in Southall, London. Photograph: Frank Baron for the Guardian
Ethnic minority pupils during an English lesson at a primary school in Southall, London. Photograph: Frank Baron for the Guardian

White British children outperformed by ethnic minority pupils, says thinktank

This article is more than 11 years old
Nine minority groups – including Bangladeshi, Ghanaian, Indian, Nigerian, Sierra Leonean and Vietnamese – are above average

White British children are outperformed at school by a wide range of ethnic minority groups, including Chinese, Sri Lankan and Nigerian youngsters, according to a thinktank.

Figures obtained under the Freedom of Information Act by the Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR) show the percentage of children classed as white British or English gaining five A* to C grades at GCSE is below the national average.

Nine minority groups of children are above the average, including Bangladeshi, Ghanaian, Indian, Sierra Leonean and Vietnamese, data reveals.

But the report adds that some groups, such as Portuguese, Congolese and Yemeni students, are underachieving.

IPPR associate fellow Jill Rutter said: "Many children of migrants perform very well in school – London has the highest proportion of migrant children in its schools, yet secondary schools in London have performed better and improved at a faster rate over the last 10 years than elsewhere in the country. But some groups are still being left behind."

The IPPR found that some migrant communities were being left behind because the government had neglected integration in favour of focusing on its key migration target.

Government attempts to help migrants fit into British society have been too heavily focused on "symbolic" issues of national identity, rather than more useful skills such as learning the English language, it said.

The thinktank argues that migrants have a responsibility to learn English to integrate and calls for English language teaching to be prioritised in a bid to tackle educational and employment problems.

"The question of integration, what happens when migrants actually arrive, has been neglected by policymakers," Rutter added.

"The government has so far failed to set out the kind of integration policies that an increasingly diverse UK needs, and has instead focused on its net migration target.

"The government needs to make the citizenship process more meaningful in order to promote integration, rather than restricting access to citizenship in order to hit its net migration target."

The IPPR said a stronger consensus within the EU about our obligations to learn the language of our host countries, even for short-term migrants, was also needed.

The report, which forms part of IPPR's Everyday Integration research programme, argues that a new approach to integration policy is needed, focused on overcoming practical barriers to integration such as poverty and unemployment.

Comments (…)

Sign in or create your Guardian account to join the discussion

Most viewed

Most viewed