System and method for normalizing job properties

US007984443B2

<12, United States Patent (10) Patent N0.: US 7,984,443 B2 Ly et al. (45) Date of Patent: Jul. 19, 2011 (54) SYSTEMAND METHOD FOR 5,414,345 A * 5/1995 Be11me1fl1- ----------------- -~ 713/104 NORMALIZING 2/222,29: .5/822 iirlzztzth .. .1 534713615 A * 11/1995 Amatsu etal. .............. .. 709/202 (75) 1I1VeI1I0rS1 AI1V- Ly, Sarasota, FL (U3); Arun 5,493,635 A 2/1996 Brindle et al. Padmanabhan, Riverview, FL (US); 5,812,843 A 9/1998 Yarnazakiet al. Edward F‘ Chen’ Sarasota’ FL (US) 5,872,930 A * 2/1393 Einlgglgiliilil 718/101 . _ _ 5873659 A. 2n999 Ed d. ruifx iiiiiiiii i (73) Asslgneel C°mP_l1teFA$$°e1ate$ Thlnk, 111°-, 5,893,905 A * 4/1999 Mziivlilt-:tSaT, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ,, 705/ll Is1and1a,NY(US) 6,076,174 A 6/2000 Freund 6,199,099 B1 3/2001 Gershman et al. ( * ) Notice: Subject to any disclaimer, the term of this 6,205,469 B1 3/2001 Gffllfilm . . * 11S5iX]§eILde(%3O91:72(l1tJuSted under 35 g:$l)esre;t:tl.aL. ............. .. 718/101 ~ ~ ~ ( I Y Ys~ 6,370,573 B1 4/2002 Bowman-Amuah ........ .. 709/223 6,438,553 B1 8/2002 Y d (21) Appl. Nd; 11/186,308 (continfizga (22) Ffledi J“1- 2°’ 2°05 FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS (65) Prior Publication Data W0 W0 96/31035 10/1996 C t' d US 2006/0017954A1 Jan. 26, 2006 ( Onmue ) OTHER PUBLICATIONS Related U.S. Application Data _ _ _ _ Martin, David, “Job Scheduling—What’s Oldis New Again . . . Sort (60) Provisional application No. 60/590,405, filed on Jul. Op», Onfinel, Feb‘ 24, 2003, pp‘ 1_2, Xp_002353991_ 22,2004. (Continued) (51) Int. C1. _ _ G061? 9/46 (200601) Primary Examiner — Kenneth Tang ' G061? 3/00 (2()()6_()1) (74) Attorney, Agent, or Firm i Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw G06F 15/1 73 (2006.01) Pmman LLP (52) U.S. C1. ....... .. 718/102; 718/100; 719/328; 709/226 57 ABSTRACT 68) IHddof(HauflkafionSemth ................ ..71&102 ( ) 718/104; 705/ 1, 9; 709/226; 358/ 1.15 This disclosure provides a system and method for normalizSee application file for complete search history. ing job properties. In one embodiment, a job manager is operable to identify a property of a job, with the job being (56) References Cited associatedwithanoperating enviromnent. The job manageris

Page 2 U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS OTHER PUBLICATIONS %/Ivcgrrory ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~ 709/102 Anonymous, “ISA Server 2004 Monitoring Features”, Onlinel, Jun. , , a et a . 6.615.261 B1 9/2003 snywrgiav ................... .. 709/224 20101155‘ §fit‘§r°2E3§§e99fi'Se Job Mm emen, I1 SP3. 616311363 B1 1°/2°03 Bmwn at al" Onlinil Jun, 30 2005 1-4 150*-002353993 g I 6’643’66l B2 U/2003 Polizzi et al' In U S l N6 11/1,8l6p128 ianon-final Office Action was mailed 6,661,526 Bl 12gggA3‘ paly et aim ................. .. 358/1.13 on Dec" lgpioog" 1 1 6,687,018 B1 2 eon et . ' ’ ' . . 6,694,345 Bl 2/2004 Brelgord et al‘ In U.S. Appl. No. 11/186,307, a non-final Office Actlon was malled 6,751,657 Bl 6/2004 Zothner ...................... .. 709/220 On Mal 16i 2°09 _ _ 6,332,263 B2 i2/2004 Polizzi ei ai In U.S. Appl. No. 11/186,128, a final Office Actlon was malled on 6,839,748 Bl 1/2005 Allavarpu et al. .......... .. 709/223 -lull 3, 20096,988,109 B2 1/2006 Stanley et al. . 707/103 Y In U.S. Appl. No. 11/186,307, a final Office Action was mailed on 7,043,728 Bl 5/2006 Galpin ........................ .. 718/102 Sep. 3, 2009, CI al. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. In N()_ 3 n()n_fin3_] Office Action was 7,136,941 B2 ll/2006 Nguyen et al. 710/15 on NOV, 30, 2009, 7,266,821 B2 * 9/2007 Polizzi et al. 718/100 _ - 7,386,586 Bl * 6/2008 Headley et al 709/202 11/186 307, a non final Office Actlon was malled 7,634,477 B2 12/2009 Hinshaw 707/10 IHUS 'A ’1 N '11/186 294 _fi loffi A t. .1 d 7,886,296 B2 2/2011 Ly et al. ...................... .. 718/100 " " PP" °' 1 1*‘ “°“ “*1 °e ° ‘°“ was ma‘ e 2002/0023122 A1 2/2002 POIIZZI et al. °“ De°~ 291 2°09 _ _ 2002/1015667 10/2002 Libra et al. ...................... .. 705/9 In U~$~ APPI N°~ 11/186189 =1 “On-final Offi“ A°“°n Was malled 2002/0194248 A1 12/2002 W666 et al. 911 Jen 6, 2010 2003/0009543 A1 1/2003 Gupta ......................... .. 709/223 In U~$~ APPI N9 11/ 186.307. =1 non-final Office Action Wes mailed 2003/0061327 A1 3/2003 Abdelhadi etal. 709/223 on May 11. 2010 2003/0110250 A1 6/2003 gehnitzer at a1, 709/224 In U.S. Appl. No. 11/ 186,128, a final Office Action was mailed on 2003/0120706 Al * 6/2003 Harjula ....................... .. 709/104 Juli 9, Z0102003/0140170 A1 7/2003 Rosensteel, Jr. et al. In U.S. Appl. No. 11/186,294, a final Office Action was mailed on 2003/0140220 Al 7/2003 Lawrance et al. Jun. 23, 2010. 2003/0212542 A1 11/2003 Lee et al. In U.S. Appl. No. 11/186,280, afinal OfficeAction was mailed on Jul. 2003/0233571 Al 12/2003 Kraus et al. ................. .. 713/200 19,2010. 2004/0098447 A1 5/2004 Verbeke et al. In U.S. Appl. No. 11/186,280, a Notice ofAllowance was mailed on 2004/0223167 Al ll/2004 Yu Sep. 29, 2010. 2004/0239981 A1* 12/2004 DUCHIO GI 211. .............. .. In U_S_ N0, 1]/186,307, 3 final Office Action was mailed on 2004/0267818 Al 12/2004 Hartenstine .............. .. 707/104.1 Oct, 23, 2010, 2005/0131865 A1 6/2005 -Tones @124 In U.S. Appl. No. 11/186,294, a non-final Office Action was mailed 2005/0165881 A1 7/2005 Brooks et al. 709/200 on NOV, i5, 2()i(), 2006/0017953 A1 1/2006 LY et a1~ 358/143 In U.S. Appl. No. 11/186,128, a non-final Office Action was mailed 2006/0017969 Al 1/2006 Ly et al. .. 358/1.15 on NOV‘ 26, 2010‘ 2006/0017975 Al 1/2006 Ly et 31' 358/1'18 In European Patent Application No. 05770206.0, a Communication 2006/0020942 A1 1/2006 Ly GI 211. ...................... .. 718/100 Pursuant to Article EPC was mailed on Jan‘ 25, 2011 by the

FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS

WO WO 02/086750 10/2002

European Patent Office.

* cited by examiner

38 //VI Em, _% 25 Em AHV wozmocrmm _wm@ 4AM zwfi Em $8 E _<_>z>@mm >c>3$ |||| wmazu Em >@>3$ GQU mmézc 3% AWV 21%.? $49 K $8 5:. a%\||.